Tags: , , , , ,

Archive for March, 2009

Appraisal Factors that Restrict Approval

Sunday, March 8th, 2009

The existence of certain physical factors may make the property ineligible for maximum financing. In such cases, the lender may reject the loan outright or impose a much lower Loan-to-Value ratio limit. Some of the factors that may cause such ineligibility include the following seven appraisal findings.
1. Economic obsolescence
2. Major functional obsolescence
3. Declining property values
4. Deferred maintenance
5. Rural property < 25% built up
6. Buildings are not typical of the area
7. Items that affect the marketability or livability of the property
When faced with any of the above conditions, the property owners must review the situation carefully. Some factors, such as functional obsolescence, deferred maintenance and livability, are within the owner’s control. Other factors, unfortunately, are not.

Information Collected By Appraisals

Sunday, March 8th, 2009

The appraisal includes a large variety of information that must be read and analyzed by the loan officer or processor. The appraisal examines the property to determine its worth and to provide the lender with a risk assessment.
Whether the house will be single-family, multi-unit, condominium or construction affects the type of information that the appraiser must gather, which partially explains why the appraisal for a four-unit building costs more than the appraisal for a single-family home.
The appraisal must contain the market value and an analysis of the following eight data categories:
1. Property & lender information
2. Neighborhood description
3. Site description
4. Improvements to the site
5. Cost approach analysis
6. Market data analysis
7. Income approach analysis
8. Reconciliation of value estimates
9. Additional support documents

How Lenders Handle Appraisals

Sunday, March 8th, 2009

For residential mortgage loan underwriters, appraisal reports normally have a shelf-life of three months. If the appraisal report is older than three months but less than twelve months old, most lenders will accept it as long as the appraiser can issue a re-certification letter, which states that the appraiser has reviewed current data and that the original value estimate is still valid.
When the appraisal report is completed, mortgage lenders will submit it to the underwriter. The underwriter will review the appraisal data to confirm that the property meets the program requirements. The underwriter will occasionally submit the report through a formal appraisal review, conducted by an in-house specialist or an independent appraiser. The goal of the appraisal review is to double-check the final value. If the appraisal review returns with a lower appraisal value, the underwriter must accept that lower value.
There are two types of appraisal reviews:

  • Desk review. Most lenders, especially for conforming loan programs, conduct simple desk reviews—nominally at their desk. Such reviews simply go through a checklist of items as they analyze he appraisal report for completeness and acceptable conclusions.
  • Field review. Many non-conforming lenders, especially when dealing with high-LTV loans, will order a field review of the appraisal. An independent third-party appraser will be contracted to review the appraisal report and then actually verify the accuracy of the data, elements and procedures used by the original appraiser.

Note that with larger jumbo loans and larger property sizes, many lenders will require a second appraisal report.
Lite Appraisals
Increasingly, many conforming lenders require and accept lighter versions of the standard appraisal report for their underwriting. Instead of a full-blown appraisal report, an exterior or “drive-by” appraisal is deemed acceptable. This exterior-only appraisals do not require the research and legwork of the standard appraisal report; so the costs are usually significantly lower.
Commercial Property Appraisals
Appraisal reports for commercial and industrial properties are more detailed and researched. As such, they tend to cost at least $1,000 for a small apartment building. They usually take a more narrative approach, unlike the residential property appraisal which uses a standard form to list the facts.

Purpose of Appraisal Reports

Sunday, March 8th, 2009

Lenders process appraisal reports with two goals in mind:
1. Determine the subject property’s fair market value.
2. Confirm that the subject property meets the parameters of the specific loan program.
The most important element that the appraisal report provides is the market value of the property. This element is the main difference between the appraisal and building inspection, which focuses the property’s structure and mechanical equipment. To compare the descriptions contained within this article with an actual appraisal report, please go to the sample appraisal report.
The appraised market value determines the LTV and consequently limits the amount of money that an applicant may borrow on a property. This appraised value normally is a reconciliation of at least two or three value calculation methods.

  • Value indicated by market data (sales comparison) approach. This is the average selling price of recently sold properties of the same type, quality and location as the subject property—with adjustments. All appraisal reports will normally contain this approach.
  • Value indicated by income approach. This estimate deals with income-producing properties and takes into account the rental rates in the property’s area, neighborhood or region.
  • Value indicated by cost approach. This estimate is based on how much it would cost to build a comparable house—less depreciation. All appraisal reports will normally contain this approach.

After obtaining the necessary data for the above valuation methods, the appraiser will then arrive at a best estimate of value. This final estimate is the appraisal value, which is determined through a reconciliation of the different value approaches.
Appraisers are not supposed to produce appraisal reports for the purpose of meeting specific valuation goals set by the party ordering the report. However, most appraisers will inform the loan officer if preliminary estimates show that the appraised value will fall below the contract price or loan target. In such a case, the full appraisal order can be canceled.